Brand Reputation and the Two Courts Framework

If you’ve been following me on LinkedIn for a while, you may have come across my discussion of the Two Courts. My attorney background is the reason why I incorporate risk analysis into every marketing and branding project. The Two Courts framework is something that every brand should think about when it comes to reputational risk. 

Marketing teams have to think about risk with every new launch, rebrand, campaign, etc. We usually think of one type of risk when there are actually two different areas. Think of risk analysis as belonging to two courts: the Court of Law and the Court of Public Opinion. Both courts are always in session, and both can issue a verdict against your brand reputation. 

The Court of Law is something that marketing teams typically consider, especially if you’ve worked in a highly regulated industry like I have. The question you start with is: what is the potential risk of a regulatory fine or a lawsuit? You think of legal and compliance risk in terms of local and global regulations, contracts, intellectual property, and other applicable laws. 

The Court of Public Opinion asks a different question entirely: will this damage our reputation? Public opinion doesn't care whether you cleared legal review. It doesn't wait for a hearing date. This court is already in session the moment you ship something new, and it renders a verdict faster than any court of law ever could.

The two courts don't always operate together or at the same time. Something can be completely legal and still be a reputational disaster. Something that looks unconventional or risky on the surface can be entirely compliant. If you're only running one check, you're only getting half the picture.

Here are a few questions to consider when thinking about how your brand reputation works in both courts. 

For the Court of Law:

  • Have I identified which laws apply in this situation? Do I need to consult with an attorney? 

  • Am I working in a regulated industry where I need to make additional compliance checks?

  • Have I made a good faith effort to identify and give proper attribution to source materials so that I am not infringing on anyone’s intellectual property rights?

  • Am I making any claims that could be perceived as false, deceptive, or misleading? 

  • If there is a contract involved, am I following the terms of the agreement?

For the Court of Public Opinion:

  • How would this perceived by someone outside of my intended audience?

  • What would happen if something I said or wrote was shared outside of context?

  • Is there anything in this campaign, announcement, or decision that I would not want to explain publicly?

  • Could the potential risk extend beyond damage to my brand? (First, do no harm.)

  • How long would it take my reputation to recover from a potential judgment by the court of public opinion? 

Neither list is exhaustive, and neither court is more important than the other. A product claim weighs more heavily towards the court of law. A brand statement on a sensitive topic would lean more towards public opinion.

The point isn't to run through every box every time. It’s to be mindful of risks, especially if you’re a solopreneur who has both a personal brand and a business brand. 

Brand strategy starts with internal criteria including your overall goals and brand values. This is why I start each client engagement with a 60-minute session to understand your priorities for your brand. 

Brand reputation is earned through every external interaction, whether with your customer or the general public. My legal background comes in handy when evaluating whether a risk is worth taking. 

Does the Two Courts framework fit in your brand strategy? If you have questions, contact me. 


I'm an attorney but I'm not your attorney. This information is not provided as legal advice or legal opinion. Consult an attorney for the applicable laws in your location.

Hana Kim

Brand Advisor + Writer

Next
Next

Why solopreneurs need a Brand Voice Guide